I think everyone of us has it’s own perception of what quality music means. Did you notice that each time you speak with someone about music of high quality vs music of low quality your music and the music you listen and appreciate come as quality music?
I have even heard of really bad, kitsch music singers saying they make quality music, being proud with what they do and sing. They are artists, making good, quality music. Not like the others…
I ask myself if is there anyone out there, making music, saying that he/she is making low quality music. Really, if there are so many making quality music, not like the others, there must be somewhere “the others” making bad music…
So, what is bad music? Who could actually say which are the criteria used to judge this low quality music? Classical music artists and critics? Technical rock artists? By the way, ask Malmsteen what he thinks about Nirvana or Smashing pumpkins…go on, ask him!
Is complexity a criteria? How about Knocking on heavens door then or No woman no cry? These could not be considered very complex from a technical point of view, right?
The easiness to reach audience? Well, is it being commercial a sin? Actually I think everybody would looove to sell million of records by night and to make it big. They will probably say that they sold so many records cause their music is good. Right! So being commercial is not it. What is it then?
Man, I feel like in Seinfeld, it was one evening when he was speaking about doctors, something like “go to my doctor, he’s the top of his class!” Everybody will say the same about his/her doctors, right? But (Seinfeld was asking himself) “what happened to those finishing medical training on the last position of the class. What happened to them? Nobody will say go to my doctor, he was the last of his class!!”
Let me hear you people!! Say it! What makes good music and what makes bad music?
miu
February 24th, 2008 at 8:46 pm
I reckon that the definition of good or bad music is a product of our environment, perception, peers, language, society, attitudes, and emotions… It’s relative…
Frank V.
February 25th, 2008 at 12:56 am
I agree with miu.
It is all relative… And I think this “relative” theory applies to more than just the art of music. (I also wonder how many people forget that music is an art form!) It applies to any art form out there, from paintings to sculptures, and even things like software design.
Everyone will have have their different opinions, and while some opinions will be more generally accepted, I think all opinions are valid.
Good music will come in many forms — you may just not want to listen to it.
Ovidiu
February 25th, 2008 at 9:21 am
You are both absolutely right. It is all relative. I think that it is given by the mass of people in the same cultural environment. And I also ask myself if it is not a certain educational level that asks this kind of questions.
I wonder if the people listening “bad” music (your own “bad” music) ask this questions.