If you are new here you may want to subscribe to my RSS feeds!

undecided what electric guitar should I buySince a few months I actively consider buying a new electric guitar since my old was way too much around and can’t handle the stress anymore…

So, lately, each time I open my computer I look for possibilities, I evaluate features, prices, shapes, pickups, tuners, sounds, artists, damn, I feel I am going crazy!

Of course, because there are so too many possibilities out there, I can not make up my mind. Of course, first I should define my needs, this should be the first step.

So, what exactly do I need? I need a versatile guitar, since I play a lot of pop rock music and alternative also, I need a guitar that allow me to go from a clean sound with personality (read sparky Fender Stratocaster) to a sweet and non aggressive distorsion tone for hard rock, to crunchy metal tones for the black side of me…

I would also like the guitar to have “the look” and have a Floyd. Period. Ah, yes, and of course, be affordable!Doh! So, let’s evaluate the possibilities…

How about an Ibanez guitar?

I love Ibanez guitars. I am a fan of Ibanez since my early years. Lovely shapes, fashionable guitars, Floyd, crunchy tone, affordable. I refer here to RG and S models, mostly. Then? Well, they don’t have that sound that only Fender provides, or the sweetness of tone, IMO. They are guitars for hard and heavy guitar player or for Satriani fans (even I am one of them, I don’t play what I preach). Also, after a tone test of an Ibanez RG against a Carvin guitar, I was so disappointed that for months I didn’t want to hear about Ibanez guitar. But, as you see, first love never dies…

Or a good old Fender Stratocaster?

I also like Fender guitars very much. They give me the sparky sound on clean, sweet distortion for rock songs. Also I have always played Fender shaped guitars so I am very familiar with the position of knobs, blade, etc. I realized that when playing a few Fender-like guitars, it came very easy to play them, comparing to playing on a Yamaha, I think, when I even hurt my pinky finger trying to turn down the volume. The knob was too close to where I had my finger and I didn’t realize so I came too hard on the knob. Of course, this is not a reason, it is just something I remember.

What I don’t like at Fender? (I speak about Fender Stratocaster). They don’t have a Floyd. I don’t have one on my current guitar but I consider having one for this next one. There is a model with Floyd but it seems like a model to please the idiot that asks for a Floyd on a Stratocaster. Namely me. So, it is is not a standard, proven solution, but kind of a hybrid. Also, prices for a good guitar, not made in China or Japan are high. But again, Ibanez is so affordable exactly because they make a lot of their guitars in Japan, I think.

Or a Jackson guitar to rock the house?!!

Yesterday I was looking at a Jackson guitar, which I love as shape and feeling. But man, the guitar I was looking at, a Randy Rhoades model, does not represent me at all. Plus that it is hard rock all over it. Too bad, a beautiful guitar. The same for the rest of Jackson models.

Variax. The guitar collection seems better than all the ones above enumerated

The one that I actually set my mind on and I really considered lately is nothing else but the Variax 600 model that I really studied in the last period of time. If it comes to being versatile, I think that we can all agree that nothing beats a Variax. Nothing CAN beat a Variax, really and I don’t think anybody would argue that. The reason is simple: every guitar, as much as you would change it, has a tone range where it can move while a Variax has 28 tone ranges…to put it this way…

Variax seems to be, so far, the one that weights the most in my options, like 70-80%. However, it has no Floyd, even if I can live with that and it is a not yet stable technology, which I am a bit afraid of, since if something happens to it, I won’t be able to fix it. With a regular electric guitar, with a screwdriver, a bit of work and an iron you can do whatever you like. With a Variax guitar, well, not quite…You need to go to the doctor.

I don’t have any problem with the fact it is a “digital” guitar and not a “regular” one. I play a processor and I am happier with it than with any stompboxes I previously owned so I am very open minded when it comes to the digital era products.

I specially love the fact that I can have my acoustic guitar and my electric guitar at a knob position away. This thrills me! Really! I have studied it, I have asked Silviu, my friends who owns one, I was speaking with him about a few of my concerns even when he was not here in Romania but on a beach in Bulgaria. Damn! I have listened to samples, recordings, live takes, the only think I would like to do is to actually play one to feel it, just that I need to take a trip to the store which is in Bucharest and I haven’t managed to find a day to go there in the last months. I must do it, I think.

So, what do you think? I am crazy or what? Considering my “needs” what would be the guitar you would advice me to buy? As you see, I haven’t considered any Gibson or Telecaster here. Even if I like them both, I wouldn’t buy one as my weapon of choice. Both have, in my opinion, too much character to fit what I want.

Any opinion would be welcome! Let me hear you!




Other people also liked these articles:
If you are new here you may want to subscribe to my RSS feeds!



8 Responses to “How not to choose an electric guitar. Take 2. Personal ramblings.”

  1. Sammy
    June 20th, 2008 at 12:16 am

    The answer, of course, is to buy one of each!

    Okay, you knew that was coming. Sorry. Since Carvin lets you choose exactly the specs you want, you might try them, but I’d find out if they have a return policy. One nice thing about where I live is that there are two guitar stores that can order what I want and return if I don’t like. Sometimes there is the risk of a restocking fee, but that’s not too large a penalty to risk.

    As for making your decision, I think you should decide exactly what your needs will be. Maybe because you have an Ibanez you could buy another desired brand and use both.

    Or possibly buy one more expensive model that is on your list and a Mexican Strat, which will satisfy your Strat craving, but at a lower cost and not too much of a quality decline.

  2. Jon
    June 20th, 2008 at 2:45 am

    Have you considered Suhr guitars? The new 24 fret modern has a floyd rose on it:

    http://www.suhrguitars.com/modern.aspx

    Trans-Charcoal… droool!

  3. Sammy
    June 20th, 2008 at 5:59 am

    Jon, I hate you. I now covet one of those Surh Moderns. The Trans-Charcoal…okay, two…I also love the denim…and the magenta.

    Stunning guitars! Not exactly cheap, though, especially when you start adding the options.

  4. Ovidiu
    June 20th, 2008 at 8:11 am

    @Sammy: In my area there is no guitar shop close by. I need to go to an other city to visit a store and for this I need to take some time off, and frankly I never manage to do it. It is an advantage to have the guitar shop in your area, I would also like this :-)

    I don’t have an Ibanez guitar, I have a guitar that is produced here in Romania, I have it since a while, it was good, but not anymore.

    I am not a Fender fan, but Fender seems to me one of the most versatile guitars, being able to play from hard rock to blues, what others can not do the right way.

    @Jon: Suhr guitars look interesting, but indeed, are not cheap under any circumstances. And to be honest I don’t remember if I have seen any in our shops in Romania.

  5. Gary Fletcher - Write Scribe
    June 20th, 2008 at 10:08 am

    For an electric and acoustic in one guitar you might take a look at the Fender Stratacoustic Deluxe. Not too expensive either…

  6. Ovidiu
    June 20th, 2008 at 10:16 am

    Well, Gary, it’s an interesting guitar but for sure not my style! When I said Fender I was thinking at a Strat plus the Floyd. Hybrids between acoustic and electric guitars are not quite my hobby ;-) Variax instead seems the only “strange” instrument I considered so far…

  7. Sammy
    June 20th, 2008 at 5:37 pm

    Ovi,

    In the last four (including current) bands I played with here are the guitars used by each main guitarist. All bands have been in the original hard rock/bordering on metal:

    ~ Carvin - not sure the model, but it was a double cutaway with HB pickups. His tone was horrible. Like a giant bumblebee. He used Carvin everything, but I don’t think it was the guitar’s fault. I think it was that he had so much stuff between guitar and preamp-then-amp that his sound was compromised.

    ~Ibanez - RG style. The guy was a phenom on guitar, but his problem was that he thought songs were written so a guitarist could solo. He had a crappy amp, but played through a Boss multi-effects board and his tone was awesome for hard rock. The clean tones were very chimey.

    ~Fender Strat - about a 1977 made in America model. This guitar was great for the clean passages, but just way too thin for our harder edge. He had to tweak his POD a lot to coax a heavier sound - and he was using a Marshall stack.

    ~My current guitarist plays mainly a Les Paul Studio and a Paul Reed Smith double cutaway. First off, he’s a wizard at finding a good tone for any song. But these guitars are insanely perfect for the sound I’ve looked for for years.

    I play a Les Paul Studio that is identical to his. I purchased mine used for $700, so I got it for close to half off a new one. The other guitar I use was cheaper and it’s a Schecter Black Jack C-1 style. No trem on either. The PRS my guitarist uses has a Floyd. So, if you can afford the PRS, I’d recommend that. It’s flexible with a five-way selector. I has the Floyd. It has 24 frets and has a familliar shape.

  8. ReviewMine
    June 21st, 2008 at 10:19 pm

    Thank you for your advice as I am novice looking to purchase a guitar.

Leave a reply

About me
Ovidiu Oprescu
Romania, 31 years
Playing the guitar since 17 and enjoying every moment of it!

Come meet me also on Mixx, StumbleUpon, Technorati, Digg, MySpace, MyBlogLog, Twitter, BlogCatalog

Also, why don't you add me to your blogroll? It's known to bring fortune and it will make you a better player! Honestly! ;-)

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

Sponsors
Remember to check our sponsors below, they keep us going on!

titanium guita picks by Superior Titanium
Gear-Vault Classifieds - eBay alternatives
Add to favorites
Don't Forget To Bookmark This Site (Hit CTRL-D)

Add to Technorati Favorites
See my REAL stats for my 5000 visitors per day dare
At the end of each month I publish my blog stats, what I have done that month and what I am going to do the next one in order to reach my target of 5000 visitors per day.
See 1st report!
See 2nd report
See 3rd report
See 4th report
See 5th report
Meta